Which Is Better?
Both photo etching and laser etching offer economical and efficient ways to make precision cuts. The method you choose will depend on the variables of the project. Some factors to consider when deciding include cost, time, design complexity, and quality. Each method offers different benefits, and the appropriate one will depend on your budget, deadline, design, and materials.
Photo Etching
Photo etching, formally called photochemical milling or machining, is also known as chemical etching because it involves the use of acid. This process is used to form components from sheet metal by corrosively machining through selective areas. The tooling is inexpensive, and complex parts can be quickly produced with a high degree of accuracy.
The process involves printing a design onto two sheets of photographic film with negative images. Parts of the metal are protected, while the areas that the acid will etch are left unprotected. When the acid is applied, the unprotected areas are etched with the design. This process works well for producing smooth cuts without burrs or sharp edges. It is a time-saving, cost-effective alternative to traditional stamping, punching, and other cutting methods.
The chemical milling process is appropriate for a variety of metals, including copper, brass, aluminum, silver, titanium, and nickel, and depends on thickness. It can be used in a number of industrial applications, such as shields and retainers, metal gaskets and seals, and battery grids. One disadvantage of this process is the thicker the material, the longer it takes the chemicals to penetrate.
Because of its ability to easily make changes to the design, photo etching is often used for prototyping. However, it can also be appropriate for mass production applications. This process etches all details simultaneously, making it a superior method for producing a variety of detailed components including fine screens and meshing, apertures and masks, battery grids, fuel cell components, and sensors.
Laser Etching
Laser etching also offers an economical method of precision cutting. The process involves the use of a high-powered, optical laser to cut materials. The laser beam is controlled by a computer and focused at the material, which is then melted, burned, or vaporized to produce the desired design.
One advantage of laser etching is it works on materials of varied thickness without increasing the time of the project. However, because it must cut individual details separately, more intricate designs take more time. Laser etching is better suited for parts with minimal complexity. Lasers work well in industrial applications to cut sheet metal and structural and piping mediums.
How to Decide
While photo etching and laser etching both offer effective alternatives to other cutting methods, each has unique applications that are better suited for specific industries. As you decide between the two methods, consider the part thickness and part complexity, as these will impact the length of the process. Material stress is another factor to think about, as laser cutting can alter the material because of the heat involved. The final consideration is cost. This will vary based on the material and the design for each method.
Resources:
Image Credit: Ilya Rabkin / Shutterstock.com