|
|
Share |
|
|
|
|
|
|
In a recent blog entry “Top 20 Innovators,” some of you took issue with the mention of General Electric’s Jack Welch in the top five. So to kick off our new regular feature–Burning Question of the Week–we ask…who else in industry is getting too much credit?
| Related Stories |
| Weekly Industry Crib Sheet: The Week after the Worst Week Yet |
| Burning Question |
| Burning Question |
And while you’re at it, feel free to suggest future Burning Questions you would like to see discussed in this blog…
-
BruceMarch 2, 2005
Most of the folks that I have encountered (whom had left GE) and have populated high posts at other companies display an arrogance which will prove to be the downfall of their new respective companies.
-
Raymond J. SmithMarch 2, 2005
Anyone who degrades the skill and ability of Bill Gates is only talking sour grapes. He did not become who he is by accident. Extreme jealousy causes some people to make negative comments about him.
-
RobMarch 2, 2005
I agree completely with the comment of Bruce. My former employer was headed by a former GE VP. His arrogance in the four years that he ran the place led him to make promises of explosive growth to the stock market, that he could not keep. In turn he bailed by selling out to a much larger firm. (Granting a hefty bonus for himself and the company VPs.)
Had he continued on the path of steady (though unspectacular) growth favored by his predecessor, this would probably still be an independent company. -
Tom WatersMarch 2, 2005
Warren Buffet. With a cash cow at his disposal, anyone could build wealth. The object is to create wealth where none was before, not just move money around.
-
HaroldMarch 2, 2005
Some people like and accept change. Every successful company has been the leader in Making business trends, not following them. That trait, amongst many others, put Jack Welch at the top. His peers, still today, rank him as the most influential businessman in the WORLD, like it or not.
If you work for GE or are an EX Employeee, you already know the difference between a company that makes their future and those that follow business trends, waiting for their fate to be decided by others in the same market. Execution of a business plan, only one key ingredient of a successful business, will only allow your company a minimum amount of ” highly profitable ” cycle time. Developing a new business philosphy, products and markets, while it is risky without the right personnel, allows a company to be profitable for a longer period; Jack grew GE from 14 Billion to 500 Billion Business over 20 years. As a stock owner and investor, you may not agree with every decision he made but you knew he made it for the right reasons, namely, to be more profitable to the investors over a sustained period of time.
-
Jim S.March 4, 2005
Bill Gates is the most overrated ??
Yes. Gates is a theif who steals or demolishes, then steals. How many examples of his brand of destruction and theivery are needed? What Gates is good at is milking a monoply position.
Grrrr . . .
-
Jim S.March 4, 2005
I also feel that Walsh of G.E. is/was far over rated.
I was always taught that: “Hatchet men are a dime a dozen.”
I deal with several G.E. divisions as a customer. Almost all of them are filled with disgrunteled employees. Most no longer even try to hide the fact.
Innovation has to be purchased by buying other companies where it is then stiffled in favor of “operating efficiencies”. This latter also goes under a number of other names, most of which are too crude to post here.
This slave driver mentality is just now beginning to take a toll. I only wonder if this trend will wind up looking like a hockey stick curve.
-
Jason KingApril 1, 2005
I’m not sure I completely agree with Jim’s post. I work for GE innovation, and every day I work with projects that were not bought from other companies, but rather are being built from customer suggestions.
If GE sees a promising company, why shouldn’t they buy it? Constantly investing in promising ventures is just smart business. It’s essentially a larger scale stock market.
There are disgruntled employees at every company. With the number of people that GE employs, odds say that there will be a good number of them throughout the GE businesses. However, I have met far more people here who have left GE and have come back than I have met disgruntled employees.
“The grass is always greener on the other side”With that said, I’m not sure that it is completely fair that Mr. Welch is named one of the top innovators. There is never just one person making all the decisions, so I do not believe just one person should get the credit. Such is life I guess, though.
|
||||
|
||||
|
Advertisement
![]() |
| Light Friday | Crib Sheet | Worth A Look |
- Weekly Industry Crib Sheet: Engineering Salaries Rise
- Weekly Industry Crib Sheet: Optimism among Industrial Manufacturers Rises
- Weekly Industry Crib Sheet: Global Skills Gap Leaves 10 Million Manufacturing Jobs Vacant
- Weekly Industry Crib Sheet: Global NC Software Market Grew in 2011
- Weekly Industry Crib Sheet: Obama’s New Task Force Highlights Importance of Natural Gas
| Also Featured in IMT |
| Expert’s Corner |
| How Food Companies Can Trim the Fat |
| The food industry is struggling to cope with market fluctuations. In this Expert’s Corner, Jonathan Daiker, a partner at CFO services firm the Interlochen Group, identifies strategies to stabilize costs and boost profits. |
| Sites We Like |
| Harvard Business Review |
| IEEE Spectrum |
| Lifehacker |
| Popular Science |
| Shopfloor |
![]() |









Browse IMT by Date
Browse IMT by Date



Bill Gates is the most overrated, in current lists of business gurus.
Martha Stewart!
She posts many straight quarterly losses and her stock gains 225% since she went to prison. She defies all the basic laws of business.